0800 014 9595

24 Hour Advice Line For Employers

The rise of ‘quiet firing’: what employers should know

At Elcons, we’re seeing a rise in enquiries linked to a growing workplace trend: ‘quiet firing’.

While not a legal term, quiet firing describes a situation where an employer appears to be deliberately making an employee’s role untenable, through neglect, withdrawal of support, or unrealistic expectations without formally dismissing them.

While some may see it as a way to encourage underperforming staff to resign, the legal risks of this approach are significant.

What is quiet firing?

Quiet firing may involve:

  • Withholding opportunities or development
  • Excluding employees from key meetings or communications
  • Reducing responsibilities without consultation
  • Setting unachievable targets
  • Offering minimal feedback or support

The intention (real or perceived) is often to nudge an employee to resign, without going through a formal dismissal process.

The legal risk: constructive dismissal

Under UK employment law, if an employee resigns due to the employer’s conduct breaching the implied term of mutual trust and confidence, they may be entitled to claim constructive unfair dismissal, even if the employer never explicitly dismissed them.

Constructive dismissal claims are not easy to win, but tribunals do look at patterns of behaviour.

Employers who isolate or undermine staff rather than addressing issues openly could find themselves exposed to legal action.

Case example

In Minto v Wernick Event Hire Ltd (2022), an employee resigned after repeated exclusion from meetings and opportunities, claiming constructive dismissal.

The tribunal found that although there was no overt dismissal, the employer’s conduct cumulatively breached trust and confidence.

This case highlights that passive management tactics can have the same legal consequences as a formal dismissal, if not handled correctly.

Elcons’ advice: fair performance management is key

At Elcons, we always advocate for transparent, structured, and fair performance management processes. If an employee is underperforming:

Use clear documentation –

Start with an informal meeting and follow up in writing. Use measurable targets and agreed timelines for improvement.

Offer support –

Training, mentoring or reasonable adjustments (especially where health or neurodiversity is a factor) can often resolve issues before escalation.

Follow a formal procedure when necessary – 

Use your disciplinary or capability procedure when performance doesn’t improve, ensuring all steps are consistent with ACAS guidance.

Avoid behaviour that could be perceived as punitive –

This includes ignoring employees, withdrawing responsibilities arbitrarily, or creating a hostile environment.

Conclusion: quiet ISN’T safe

‘Quiet firing’ might seem like an easier route but it’s legally risky and damaging to workplace morale.

Employers must remember that transparency, fairness and communication are not only best practice, but they’re also essential protections.

If you’re unsure whether your performance management practices are compliant or at risk of legal challenge, Elcons Employment Law can guide you through every step, from policy reviews to complex case handling.

📞 Contact us today for further advice: 0800 014 9595

Reviews