0800 014 9595

24 Hour Advice Line For Employers

The cost of getting TUPE wrong: Lessons from recent cases

When a business changes hands, whether through a sale, merger, outsourcing or bringing services back in-house, there’s one law that often causes confusion: TUPE.

TUPE stands for the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) regulations.

In simple terms, TUPE is there to protect employees when the business or service they work for changes ownership. It means their employment should continue as if nothing has changed, the new employer steps into the old employer’s shoes.

What TUPE means in practice

If TUPE applies, the new employer must:

  • Take on the staff doing the work (not pick and choose who they want).
  • Keep their terms and conditions the same, including pay, holiday and honour their continuous service.
  • Consult properly with affected staff or their representatives before the transfer happens. Consultation involves holding meaningful conversations, giving the employee time to ask questions and raise any areas of concern.

Ignoring or misunderstanding any of these obligations can be very costly.

Recent case lessons

  1. Failing to consult = automatic unfair dismissal
    In one recent case, employees were told about the transfer only after it had taken place. They hadn’t been consulted or given a chance to raise concerns.
    The employment tribunal ruled that this was a serious breach, each employee was awarded the maximum 13 weeks’ pay as compensation. For larger workforces, that can add up fast.
  2. Changing terms and conditions after the transfer
    Another employer tried to “harmonise” contracts by giving transferred staff the same terms as their existing team. Sounds fair in theory, but under TUPE, any changes linked to the transfer are automatically void, even if the employee agrees. The result? The company faced multiple claims for unlawful deduction of wages and breach of contract.
  3. Overlooking agency or shared staff
    A service provider took over a cleaning contract but only transferred half the team, assuming the rest were agency staff. It turned out several were regular employees under TUPE. The tribunal ordered back pay and compensation for the dismissed workers, and the client business ended up jointly liable too.

The financial and reputational cost

Getting TUPE wrong doesn’t just mean legal fees. Employers can face:

  • Compensation awards of up to 13 weeks’ pay per employee for failing to inform and consult.
  • Compensation for unfair dismissal claims.
  • Legal costs, disruption, and damage to staff morale and reputation.

In many cases, businesses also lose trust with incoming or outgoing partners, making future transfers much harder.

How to avoid TUPE pitfalls

  1. Get early advice – before contracts are signed or staff are informed.
  2. Identify who is affected – including part-time, casual, shared employees and those on maternity leave.
  3. Consult properly – with clear timelines and honest communication.
  4. Keep records – document decisions, communications and handovers.
  5. Work with HR and legal specialists who understand TUPE inside and out.

Final thoughts

TUPE isn’t just red tape: it’s about protecting people during times of change.

Handled well, it helps retain skills, maintain goodwill, and ensure a smooth transition. Handled badly, it can lead to expensive claims, lost trust, and a reputation that’s hard to repair.

If you’re planning a restructure, merger or contract transfer, our consultants at Elcons Employment Law can guide you through the process safely, protecting your business and your people.

📞 Contact us today for further advice: 0800 014 9595

Reviews